Close Close
Mother and Baby

US Doctors Claim Water Births Are Unsafe – Would You Still Have One?

Section: Labour & Birth

New reseach claims giving birth in water could be dangerous as it increases the risk of infections and breathing problems in your baby

Easing yourself into a warm bath or birthing pool can be extremely helpful in easing contraction pains and calming mums-to-be during labour.

But new guidelines released by the American Academy of Paediatrics and American College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists have said that underwater delivery should be limited as it could lead to ‘rare but serious’ problems in newborns, including potentially lethal infections and problems with breathing.

The researchers did point out that the risks occurred if you stayed in the pool during the second stage of labour – where you start pushing and deliver the baby – and that labouring in water during the early stages could still be very beneficial.

It is estimated that at least one in 100 women use a birthing pool at some point during labour – around 7,000 a year in England in Wales, and some of these women will also remain in the water to give birth.

Co-author of the study, Dr Jeffrey Ecker, said that although he has cared for many women who were comforted by the pool early in labour, that is not the same as the baby being born underwater.

However, some believe that the change in guidelines is a sign of the more cautious approach that the US takes to giving birth.

The National Childbirth Trust said the US tends to ‘medicalise’ birth more than the UK. Elizabeth Duff, a senior policy advisor at the charity, said, ‘I know a lot of midwives who look after water births and say they are fantastic.’

What have been your experiences of using a birthing pool during labour? Let us know in the comment box below.

Related content:


No comments have been made yet.

Subscribe to Mother&Baby!

Be the best mum you can be and let Mother & Baby guide you along the way. Each issue is jam packed with REAL advice from mums just like you. Subscribe today & get a free welcome gift!

Win £1,000 of Carpetright vouchers
Win £1,000-worth of Carpetright vouchers!

Create a fantasy world on your floor with your baby for your chance to win £1,000-worth of Carpetright vouchers!

Win an Abeille cellular blanket from Hippychick
Win an Abeille cellular blanket from Hippychick

Abeille Cellular Blankets, available fromHippychick, are delectably soft, made from 100% cotton and now available in six super-stylish colours. Click for your chance to win!

Win a year’s supply of Blueiron liquid iron supplement
Win a year’s supply of Blueiron liquid iron supplement

Blueiron is Scandinavia’s fastest-growing liquid iron supplement and has already helped thousands of women low in iron during pregnancy, breastfeeding and those with intense fitness regimes. Click for your chance to win!

Win a bumper box of Kiddylicious Super Snacks
Win a bumper box of Kiddylicious Super Snacks

Made from quinoa, lentils and chickpeas, and packed with vegetable protein, Kiddylicious Super Snacks help to keep your little ones whizzing about. Click for your chance to win!

Ovulation Calculator
Ovulation calculator

Trying for a baby? Work out when you're most fertile to increase your chances of getting pregnant with our easy-to-use ovulation calculator.

Pregnant woman
Due Date Calculator

When is your baby due? If you’re having trouble remembering dates and counting up the days on your fingers and toes, don’t worry – use our due date calculator.

Get M&B in your inbox!

Sign up to Mother&Baby today and get news and advice about your body and your baby straight to your inbox every week.