Close Close
Mother and Baby

Would You Rather Have A Long Less Painful Labour Or A Short Painful One? A Survey Of Mums-To-Be Has Shown One's Come Out Top…

Section: Labour & Birth
Would You Rather Have A Long Less Painful Labour Or A Short Painful One?

Labour can be one of the most daunting parts of having a child and even with a detailed birth plan, it can be hard to prepare for what’s ahead. But, if you had the choice, what would you opt for?

A study, led by Dr Brendan Carvalho from the Stanford University School of Medicine in California, questioned 40 expectant mothers whether they’d prefer a longer labour with relatively less pain, or a shorter labour with excruciating pain.
The majority of expecting mothers answered that they’d rather endure a longer labour with less pain, according to the findings published in the British Journal of Anaesthesia.

Carvalho said: 'Interestingly, intensity is the driver.

‘Using an epidural may prolong labour but reduces pain intensity, and it seems that could be preferable to most,' he said.

Take Our Quiz! Which Labour Pain Relief Is Right For You?

The women taking part in the study were given a seven-item questionnaire as they arrived at hospital to have labour induced but before painful contractions began. A sample question asked: 'Would you rather have pain intensity at two out of 10 for nine hours or six out of 10 for three hours?'

The women took the survey a second time within 24 hours of giving birth. The survey pitted hypothetical pain level, on a scale of zero to 10, against hours of labour.

Both pre and post-labour, women taking part on average preferred less intense pain over a longer duration, according to the findings.

Dr Carvalho said: 'Labour’s got a lot of factors to it, it’s difficult to capture in one score.'

'The one good thing that does happen in labor is we use patient controlled analgesia.

'Women control how much medication they get, which is better than getting prescribed a set dose from start to finish.

'More medication makes legs heavy, may make labour longer and will more likely involve forceps or vacuum (to help deliver the baby), and less medication means more intense pain and also the ability to be more active.'

'Women would benefit from more conversation about this,' he added.

Did your labour go as you planned? Let us know below!



Related content:


No comments have been made yet.

Subscribe to Mother&Baby!

Be the best mum you can be and let Mother & Baby guide you along the way. Each issue is jam packed with REAL advice from mums just like you. Subscribe today & get a free welcome gift!

Win £1,000 of Carpetright vouchers
Win £1,000-worth of Carpetright vouchers!

Create a fantasy world on your floor with your baby for your chance to win £1,000-worth of Carpetright vouchers!

Win an Abeille cellular blanket from Hippychick
Win an Abeille cellular blanket from Hippychick

Abeille Cellular Blankets, available fromHippychick, are delectably soft, made from 100% cotton and now available in six super-stylish colours. Click for your chance to win!

Win a year’s supply of Blueiron liquid iron supplement
Win a year’s supply of Blueiron liquid iron supplement

Blueiron is Scandinavia’s fastest-growing liquid iron supplement and has already helped thousands of women low in iron during pregnancy, breastfeeding and those with intense fitness regimes. Click for your chance to win!

Win a bumper box of Kiddylicious Super Snacks
Win a bumper box of Kiddylicious Super Snacks

Made from quinoa, lentils and chickpeas, and packed with vegetable protein, Kiddylicious Super Snacks help to keep your little ones whizzing about. Click for your chance to win!

Ovulation Calculator
Ovulation calculator

Trying for a baby? Work out when you're most fertile to increase your chances of getting pregnant with our easy-to-use ovulation calculator.

Pregnant woman
Due Date Calculator

When is your baby due? If you’re having trouble remembering dates and counting up the days on your fingers and toes, don’t worry – use our due date calculator.

Get M&B in your inbox!

Sign up to Mother&Baby today and get news and advice about your body and your baby straight to your inbox every week.